After all these years Catelyn still hated Jon Snow. She can’t accept him as a son. It didn’t mean she hadn’t tried but she was just not able to do it (She had conversation with Talisa Stark about how she is not able to accept Jon Snow as her own son)
Did Catelyn regret hating Jon?
After watching a nonexistent scene in the books in which Catelyn shows regret for wishing Jon to leave, and the young bastard almost died from a pox, she felt guilty for having previously condemned an innocent child because she was jealous of his mother.
Does Catelyn know about Jon Snow?
Her hatred was necessary in order to keep Jon safe and secret. “ A second agreed: “ No, Catelyn definitely did not know. … At some point, she does ask him about Jon and he snaps at her (the only time he did that) and tells her Jon is his blood, that’s all she needs to know and never to bring up that subject again.”
How did Catelyn treat Jon Snow?
Catelyn, consumed by grief for her father and her home and worry for her sons, snaps that only a mother can do it. And then she calms down and explains that she’s only made prayer wheels twice before. … And she promised her seven gods that if Jon Snow lived, she would treat him like a son and ask Ned to name him Stark.
Who did Catelyn Stark love?
Catelyn was originally betrothed to Eddard’s older brother Brandon Stark, the heir to Winterfell at the time. When Brandon was sadistically executed by King Aerys II, Lord Jon Arryn, who was the guardian of Eddard and Robert Baratheon, rebelled against House Targaryen.
So forgive me if this has already been brought up. But its always struck me that Catelyn‘s fatal mistake, the one that comes long before her many maneuvers that lead to disaster, is her treatment of Jon Snow.