German Shepherds and Rottweilers are both large breed dogs categorized as herding and working dogs, respectively, by the American Kennel Club. Their role as family guard dogs, police dogs, or service dogs depicts their fame as strong and reliable breeds.
Whether you are trying to solve the strength puzzle because you are considering owning one of these dogs or are just curious about how the two breeds compare, this article has all the answers for you. But Ill give you all the help you need by exploring the strength-related features of German Shepherds and Rottweilers so that you have all the information you need to solve your puzzle.
You can also check out this really cool 6-minute video from ViralBe. Its their take on the ultimate showdown between the Rottweiler vs. the German Shepherd: In fact, a full-grown Rottweiler has a stout build which, coupled with its mean-looking face, will intimidate the strongest of men. As for the German Shepherd, Captain Max von Stephanitz, who is credited with the creation of the German Shepherd Dog as we know it today, was attracted by the breeds intelligence and working strength: two traits that make a sturdy herding dog.
As an example, my female German Shepherd is really big for a girl, nevertheless, she is proportionally built, which is what counts she stands at 27 tall and weighs 88lbs (40kg)! If we were to stop here and gauge the strength of the two breeds by these physical aspects, we would hand over the trophy to the Rottweiler. Temperament and personality in dogs are used to explain their behavioral responses in the face of an internal or external stimulus.
In fact, a study done in Mexico in 2018 found that 11 of the 22 tested breeds recorded a high frequency of SOD1, the allele associated with the disease. The German Shepherd is equally active and athletic and will enjoy plenty of exercise for his mental and physical wellbeing. The UK Kennel Club recommends more than 2 hours of exercise per day for both the German Shepherd and Rottweiler, which could suggest equal energy levels for the two breeds.
As pastoral dogs, German Shepherds are usually expected to follow orders and be fierce defenders. On the flip side, Rottweilers as working dogs are expected to use their muscular bodies to guard and pull carts. However, both breeds today are loving and loyal family pets and are often trained to be service and therapy dogs.
Deciding how strong each of the two breeds is can be weighed on many factors, including their physical build, their personality, the amount of exercise they can take per day, their health, and their life expectancy. She has a German Shepherd named Willow and as a former Police Officer, she worked with dogs for almost 30 years.
Is a Rottweiler stronger than a German Shepherd?
German Shepherds are not stronger than Rottweilers, that is if by strong you mean how sturdy they are. German Shepherds are a lot smaller in weight and have a less muscular build than Rottweilers.
Why do police use German Shepherds instead of Rottweilers?
While strength is an admirable trait for a police dog, it is also important to reduce damages where possible during apprehension. This makes the German Shepherd more suitable for suspect apprehension, in some cases. For these reasons, some police departments prefer the German Shepherd over the Rottweiler.
What dog can beat a German Shepherd?
In fact, German Shepherds have a size and weight advantage, as well as a stronger bite force. However, pitbulls are bred to be fighting dogs, so a well-trained, well-fed, and aggressive pitbull can also beat a German Shepherd.
Which dog can beat Rottweiler?
Which dog can kill a Rottweiler? Pit bulls are faster and more athletic then Rotties. They also were breed for dog fighting so they have the edge there. However Rottweilers are far bigger then pitbulls and have a stronger bite force.
Whether youre looking for a family pet or a dog to protect your business, you may have considered adopting a Rottweiler or a German Shepherd Dog. Both of these large dogs can intimidate people and animals. But dont be fooled by their athletic build or the myths surrounding these canines.
As they bred with local dogs, farmers began using the strong canines to drive their cattle to the marketplace. Once clients purchased the meat, it is said they would put the money in purses strapped to the dogs necks for safekeeping.
By the time of the industrial revolution, cars and trains moved market supplies, so dogs were no longer needed. Even though Rottweilers continued to be used as police and service dogs , they werent as active in the military as some other breeds. In the 18th century, a military man named Captain Max von Stephanitz sought to create the perfect herding dog .
German Shepherds have the option of four coat types , short, medium, and long, all with an undercoat. Both dogs can be extremely good with children , and many families swear each breed as being the best theyve ever owned. Socializing these dogs adequately by bringing them around strangers from an early age can prevent antisocial behavior and can keep them friendly.
If you think thats a lot, consider the American Kennel Club recommends German Shepherds get at least two hours of exercise per day . Families who dont have time to give much attention to a dog might consider getting a Rottie instead of a Shepherd. To keep your German Shepherd active and entertained, test a variety of different dog toys and see which ones work best for your pup.
Both breeds are highly trainable and do well as law enforcement or military dogs.Rottweiler owners should commit to training their dogs correctly. You can help to keep your German Shepherds hips and joints in top shape by using glucosamine supplements and making sure they have a soft but firm dog bed to rest on. Another concern for the Shepherd is degenerative myelopathy, which is a progressive spinal disease that occurs from eight years onward.
A proper diet is crucial for such large and active dogs.The Rottie eats slightly more of the two breeds, which is expected given his size. German shepherds typically eat between 2.5 to 3.5 cups of high-quality kibble per day, also depending on their size, gender and growth needs. For potentially dominant dog breeds such as these guys, its important to make them work for their food rather than giving it to them for free.
The Shepherd is more popular, meaning there are more breeders, which affects the supply and demand depending on where you live. Although there isnt a huge difference, the cost of a Rottie over his lifetime will likely be more than a Shepherd due to their size. Rotties are large to giant-sized dogs, and bigger products usually come with a higher price tag , including beds, crates, harnesses , toys, etc.
These dogs arent ideal for a small home or an area without a large yard unless youre planning to take them for several long walks a day.
Were going to explore the specifics of each breed here and really drill down into the details and present to you where the differing breeds, well Differ!
Both German Shepherds and Rottweilers are iconic dogs, recognizable almost instantly. Rotties and GSDs are quite distinct in their potential health issues, their temperaments and, of course, their physical appearance.
Picking the right dog for your situation is essential to a long and happy relationship. This guide is all about helping you decide whether your home is more suited to welcoming a Rottweiler or a German Shepherd into it. Now, theres a good chance that you and your kin would make a fantastic family for any number of types of dogs.
Specialized and intentional breeding has created slight variations within the breed, but dont be fooled into buying into the idea of the American Rottweiler or the German Rottweiler. The main difference is that the German show line requires hip certification to prove that work is being done to discourage the famously bad hip problems that Shepherds suffer from. Each requires the dog to be hard working, agile and mentally stable.
But the German lines have more emphasis on the dogs ability to settle down in a home environment. When were comparing the Rottweiler vs German Shepherd dogs well be looking mostly at the breeds in general, though we will refer to type if it becomes relevant. Rottweilers are believed to come from the large drover dogs of Ancient Rome.
They would be primarily utilised as guarders of cattle and other livestock, watching over their herds and flocks intently. The early standard for pedigree Rottweilers was established in Germany way back in 1901. With the first Rotties coming over to America and Britain just before the Second World War.
Ironically, their popularity in the UK grew as they were used as police and military dogs throughout the war against Germany. Compared to Rottweilers, German Shepherds are a rather young breed of dog. They were bred as the ultimate Shepherd and have a man called Max von Stephanitz to thank for their popularity.
A former cavalry captain and ex-student of the Berlin Veterinary College, von Stephanitz was an ex-member of The Phylax Society, a dog development institution. The retired soldier nurtured and lauded the breed, espousing its values and pretty quickly convincing the world that the Schferhunde is the very best in large Shepherd dog. As with Rottweilers, German Shepherds made their way out to the rest of Western Europe and into America in the 1930s, quickly establishing themselves as immensely popular working dogs and pets.
Neither are the worlds largest breed of dog, that honor belongs to the Great Dane. But dont underestimate just how big and heavy Rotties and German Shepherds can get. Years of humans utilizing large dogs like Rottweilers and German Shepherds as guard dogs and using them in the military and in police forces has earned them both an unfair reputation.
Anyone with a working knowledge or even brief amount of experience with either breed of dog will know that that they are neither violent nor aggressive when trained. The large teeth and loud bark of the GSD and the stout build and mean-looking angry face of a fully-grown Rottweiler may look intimidating. Both breeds can be big softies if trained and socialized correctly, and bred from friendly parents.
It is equally important with both to meet the pups parents and assess their temperaments, as well as to really thoroughly socialize the puppy from the day they come home. However, both breeds are often wary of strangers if not thoroughly socialized, and have been known to become aggressive even with their own families. One study has shown that 15% of dogs with severe aggression are German Shepherds and around 5% by Rottweilers.
German Shepherds have been shown in several studies to be a high risk breed for bites, even when the odds were adjusted to take into account their popularity. Rottweilers and GSDs are calm and self-assured, but Rotties tend to be a little more aloof and able to enjoy their own company more. The only possible downside to the temperaments of these animals comes from their natural instincts.
Theyre both herding dogs by nature, but guarding is also a huge strength of both breeds. In order to help a Rottweiler or German Shepherd fit into your home, the key is socialization. You are duty bound (not to mention legally required) to ensure that your dog is safe.
From noisy babies, to the elderly, people in bright clothing to men with beards. Once they are three months old you can reduce the intensity, but it will still need to be at least a couple of times a week. Youre on an even keel when it comes to Rottweiler vs German Shepherd socialization.
There is little contrast in the way a dog owner should approach training a Rottweiler or GSD. Extensive training is also needed to ensure that Rottweilers and German Shepherds are obedient, especially went out walking in public. They both have high canine IQs and can learn and retain new information with just a few repetitions.
Where some real differences emerge is when we start to look at Rottweiler vs German Shepherd Dog health. But its to do a disservice to your pet to ignore the very distinct possibility that, one day, they might get sick. But there is one major health issue that Rottweilers and German Shepherds share
Dysplasia refers to the abnormal function of any major joint and leads to discomfort, lameness, arthritis and extreme pain in some cases. Dont let it put you off the breeds though, just make sure that you only buy a puppy whose parents both have good hip and elbow scores. Rotties have a slightly higher chance of developing osteosarcoma, or bone cancer.
They also have a higher chance of suffering with von Willebrands Disease (vWD), a bleeding disorder not dissimilar to haemophilia. Progressive Retinal Atrophy (PRA) is also noted as an affliction more prevalent among Rottweilers than many other breeds. Potential owners should also be aware that Rottweilers sometimes show a tendency to suffer with thyroid problems and Panosteitis, an inflammation of the bones in the limbs.
If you buy a Rottie puppy youll need to make sure the parents also have clear PRA DNA tests, clear vWD tests and no family history of the other issues. Its an incurable disease of the spinal cord caused by a gene mutation. German Shepherds are predisposed to suffer with musculoskeletal diseases and problems more than almost any other breed of dog.
The average German Shepherd, compared to a Rottweiler, will live longer. It doesnt matter which breed of dog you end up choosing, you should go about selecting a breeder and puppy the same way. Youll want someone who knows their stuff, only expects their dogs to produce one litter a year maximum and generally seems above board.
With guarding breeds its also a good idea to meet the father, to make sure of his temperament. If youre able to adopt instead of shop, the fees you pay will dictated by the rescue center and probably just cover costs. You can double those figures for a breedable and/or show quality young pup.
Both German Shepherds and Rottweilers can be viewed as controversial choices, due to their guarding natures. But despite their big sizes and fearsome reputations, both German Shepherds and Rottweilers can make great family pets. We hope youve enjoyed reading this guide to both breeds and that its helped compare the doggy duo.
The intention was that this article comes in handy for anyone choosing between a Rottweiler and a German Shepherd. With a little bit of luck youve now got a better understanding of both breeds and youre some way closer to being able to make a decision. Brazil-Adelman, Dr. M, The German Shepherd Dog Handbook, 2010 Blackmore, J, A Dog Owners Guide to the Rottweiler, 1997 Leighton, E.A, Genetics of Canine Hip Dysplasia, Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association, 1997 Mackenzie, S.A, Heritability Estimate for Temperament Scores in German Shepherd Dogs and its Genetic Correlation with Hip Dysplasia, Behavior Genetics, 1984 ONeill, DG, Longevity and Mortality of Owned Dogs in the UK, The Veterinary Journal, 2011 JK Blackshaw.
German Shepherds and Rottweilers are both incredibly popular dog breeds in America, although these two breeds differ in some important ways that you will want to know if you are thinking of bringing one home.
They do, however, possess several key differences in shedding and friendliness towards people and animals that must be taken into consideration when choosing between the two breeds. Its very important to know these differences as they can influence your decision to choose, and eventually, your experience as a dog owner.
In this article, we will compare the two breeds in many aspects with the hope of helping you decide which better dog is for you. This is mostly because a dogs personality has to match well with that of the owner, so that a peaceful and enjoyable relationship between the two can occur and last for a long time. They originated as herding dogs in the 19th century by a German military officer and ex-veterinary student named Max Emil Friedrich von Stephanitz , who was impressed by the intelligence and agility of the German sheepdogs he saw in the countryside where he used to live.
While the GSDs are popular for their positive characteristics, they are also widely known to be the cause of many dog bites in America . They originated as herding dogs for the cattle that the Roman empire brought with them through Germany. In the past, aside from herding, Rottweilers also pulled carts which contained meat and bring them to the markets.
Today, Rottweilers mostly serve as working dogs, performing serious tasks such as herding cattle and guarding humans and their property. PROSCONSGERMAN SHEPHERD Loyal, intelligent, protective, affectionate, and industriousProne to boredom, can be aggressive if left untrained ROTTWEILLER Loyal, intelligent, protective, and obedientCan be aloof especially to strangers, prone to boredom and aggression if left untrained, can be stubborn The size of a dog is another important factor that anyone must consider in choosing one. An average adult German Shepherd can measure about 22-26 inches in height (55-65 cm) and weigh around 75-96 lbs (34-43 kg) .
Additionally, their size and strength makes them a perfect candidate for simple jobs such as carrying your items or closing the door. Likewise, this can be annoying for smaller pets who can be hurt simply by rough playing with a massive dog. The stocky build of a Rottweiler makes them durable and capable of performing heavy tasks such as pulling carts.
Due to their size, Rottweilers have lower energy levels than GSDs and are therefore prone to obesity. PROSCONSGERMAN SHEPHERD Sturdy, adaptable to changes, eager to workProne to obesity, their need for constant exercise can be too much for less active owners, their power can be too much for those without the physical strength to handle them and dangerous around kids ROTTWEILLER Sturdy, adaptable to changes, eager to workProne to obesity, their need for constant exercise can be too much for less active owners, their power can be too much for those without the physical strength to handle them and dangerous around kids Many people living in apartments, especially those who live alone, consider getting a dog for companionship. Having a dog definitely lessens the feeling of loneliness and adds comfort and affection to an otherwise solitary space.
Several factors contribute to whether a specific breed is compatible with a smaller space or bigger houses with fenced yards. But you should be prepared to meet the following conditions to provide your GSD an good life while living in a relatively small space: In some states, apartments impose breed-restriction laws on their tenants, which means that there are specific breeds that are not permitted.
The idea behind these laws is to prevent dog attacks by potentially dangerous breeds. In the case of the latter, their decision must be respected and you are left with the choice of moving to another apartment that accepts GSDs or choosing another breed. If your apartment does not have a spacious area where you can exercise your dog, it must at least have a nearby park that you can visit everyday.
As a rule of thumb, your German Shepherd must haveat least 30 minutes to 1 hour of exercise daily. You should not leave your GSD alone for long periods of time, as they are prone to separation anxiety . If your apartment has weak soundproofing or thin walls, this can be very annoying for your neighbors who only want to live peacefully inside their units.
Rottweilers can cope living inside apartments, but keep in mind that adult Rotts are more suitable for this type of space than puppies because of their lower energy levels. Apartments, of course, do not always have this luxury, so you will have to utilize nearby parks and safe sidewalks for your dogs exercise needs. When a Rott puppy becomes an adult, he will naturally become less active, so living in an apartment will not be much of a problem.
However, a Rottweiler will still need sufficient daily exercise to prevent weight gain, since Rotts, being naturally heavyset, are very prone to obesity. This aspect can be accomplished at the same time that youre taking your dog to the park for exercise, where he will most likely meet other people and animals, too. But if you leave your Rott alone in the apartment for several hours, he may become bored and anxious and act out by destroying things, digging, barking incessantly, whining, or peeing everywhere.
PROSCONSGERMAN SHEPHERD Very adaptable to lifestyle and environment changes, excellent guard dogs, can provide good emotional support especially for solo owners Has a high tendency to nip or chew on things, gets bored easily, needs constant daily exercise, can scare off neighbors, prone to separation anxiety, often part of prohibited breeds in apartments, heavy shedders, can exhibit aggression problems if untrained ROTTWEILER Adults can cope well in apartment living, excellent guard dogs, presents minimal sheddingHas an average tendency to nip or chew on things especially when bored, needs constant daily exercise to manage weight and temperament, can scare off neighbors, more prone to separation anxiety, has a higher need for socialization, often part of prohibited breeds in apartments, notorious for their aggression problems especially if untrained Both German Shepherds and RottweilerS are massive dogs, which is why many people often wonder if they are safe to be around children. Heres the short answer: both German Shepherds and Rottweilers can be great around kids, as long as they have been properly trained and socialized from an early age. However, you need to set up your GSD for success first so that a safe, fun, and loving relationship can grow between your children and your dog.
To do that, you must first understand that the GSDs natural tendency to protect can easily turn bad if this trait has not been properly nurtured. Early training and socialization with children are your best tools for managing your dogs temperament, eliminating bad behaviors, and keeping aggressive tendencies at bay. Below are some general pointers to remember that will foster a harmonious relationship between your GSD and your child:
The best way to turn your GSD from an overprotective, fearful dog into a welcoming and friendly companion is to expose him to kids as early as possible. Actually, regardless of whether you have kids or not, socialization is a key part of training that is most responsible for a dog that is well-behaved around people other than the owner. If you have a child and you want to ensure that your dog will behave well around him or her, a great deal of consistent socialization is a must.
Training simply makes it easier for you to command your dog so that you can manage him easily while youre out in public. Similarly, a simple command can prevent any untoward incidents from occurring between your dog and your child. Simply speaking, a dog that is well-exercised keeps the high energy at bay, thus preventing excited behavior from harming your child.
To understand all about German Shepherd puppy biting and how to curb this undesired behavior, be sure to read this excellent article that weve written for you: As a responsible parent and pet owner, you must also train your child to behave appropriately towards your dog. Unfortunately, many parents overlook this aspect, putting all the blame on the poor dog whenever ugly situations occur.
This is because both breeds are huge, intelligent guard dogs with an inherent desire to protect their owners. But for Rottweilers and children to hang out together peacefully, the same key principles must be followed: socialization, training, exercise, education, and supervision. The only difference, perhaps, is that Rottweilers need firmer obedience training because they have the tendency to be stubborn , especially the males.
They are quite intelligent dogs that can pick up commands easily, but they are at times known to challenge their owners during training. In addition to the previous sections guidelines, here are some pointers you must keep in mind to set up a safe and successful relationship between your child and Rottweiler: A Rottweilers huge size means that it can handle rough play from your child.
If proper training and socialization have been accomplished early on and boundaries have been established between the child and your dog, you can rest assured that your Rottweilers aggressive tendencies will rarely present and a healthy friendship can exist. PROSCONSGERMAN SHEPHERD Excellent guard dogs for children, affectionate and playful, intelligent and easy to trainHigh energy and huge size can unintentionally hurt kids; early training and socialization is a must, otherwise aggressive tendencies may present; not for novice parents who dont have the time to train; if untrained, its high prey drive can cause it to see kids as prey ROTTWEILER Excellent guard dogs for children, gentle and playful, intelligent Huge size can unintentionally hurt kids; early training and socialization is a must, otherwise aggressive tendencies may present; can be stubborn during training; not for novice parents who dont have the time to train; males mature slower and tend to have dominant personalities; prone to jealousy While a dogs breed can determine its behavioral tendencies, the way a dog responds towards other animals is still dependent on many factors, including its upbringing and past experiences with other animals. Generally, German Shepherds can live peacefully with other dogs in the house provided that they have been socialized early.
Socialization means exposing your GSD to other dogs, animals, people, places, and senses. This helps your dog adjust his behavior towards creatures other than him and teaches him the idea that not everything that moves is a prey. Ideally, you should start socializing your dog at 3 to 12 weeks of age , when hes still a blank canvas for absorbing new behavior.
Lack of socialization is perhaps the number one reason why German Shepherds show aggression to other dogs. There is a sudden change in lifestyle or the environment, such as moving into another location or welcoming a new member of the family. While GSDs are generally adaptable and flexible, individual dogs can still exhibit different responses.
Your GSD is exhibiting what is called resource guarding , or protecting a certain item too much, such as food or a toy. In such cases, its important to trace the root cause so you can come up with the proper solution and remove the aggressive behavior. But it may still depend on the individual personalities of both animals and their past experiences which may shape their present reactions.
While many of todays GSDs are more often seen doing police work than herding sheep, the prey drive is still there and it manifests in different ways . In the video below, you can see an adult GSD acting suspicious of the familys new kitten at first, but in the end the two become best friends! The keys to preventing a disastrous first meeting is to start slow , create a safe space for the cat where she can be protected from a potential attack (e.g. a crate), and leash your dog.
Make sure that your dog is trained first and follows basic commands such as Stop or Stay before introducing him to any cat. The most important requirement for setting up a peaceful relationship between a Rott and another dog is your training and supervision. Because Rotts tend to have dominant personalities, you must firmly establish your position as its leader so that he does not boss you around.
Armed with the knowledge that Rotts can have aggressive tendencies, it is your responsibility as the owner then to make sure that your dog is even-tempered. In public parks, it is good practice to always keep your Rott in a leash unless youre ABSOLUTELY sure that it is not going to harm anyone. In fact, in some countries like Singapore , muzzling a Rottweiler (or a German Shepherd) is required when visiting public areas.
Proper muzzling also requires training, so be sure to start at an early age so that your pup becomes accustomed to it. Always remember to supervise your dog at all times even if he is trained, as he can snap into instinctive protective behavior if he perceives something as a threat. Rottweilers and cats can live together peacefully inside the same house provided that they have been properly socialized together when they are young.
German Shepherds and the Rottweiler have essentially the same grooming requirements with a few small differences. Keep in mind, however, that German Shepherds will require more brushing because they are heavy shedders, which can be attributed to their thick double coats. Use shampoo thats not too harsh on the skin and that contains natural ingredients that help improve the texture and smell of your dogs fur.
Dental care : Like humans, dogs also need their teeth cleaned to keep their breath fresh and to prevent mouth diseases. Some adult Rotts with dominant personalities may feel uncomfortable with being brushed all the way down the back. PROSCONSGERMAN SHEPHERD Generally low maintenance grooming required, hair does not need shaving or stylingHeavy shedder that requires daily brushing, many GSDs have black nails which are tricky to trim, prone to skin allergies, huge body requires more effort to bathe ROTTWEILLER Generally low maintenance grooming required, hair does not need shaving or styling, minimal brushing requiredHave black nails that are tricky to trim, huge body requires more effort to bathe, prone to skin allergies, moderate shedder Both the GSD and the Rottweiler have a host of health problems that are common to large breeds.
However, unlike the GSDs, they are more prone to having vision problems that eventually lead to blindness. In that case, its your responsibility to take proper care of your pet so that he or she will live a full life. Knowing that large breeds tend to have several health problems, you can prolong your dogs life by taking care of the following:
Simply speaking, you will spend more money on big dogs than on smaller ones because they eat more, require bigger-sized items such as crates and toys. Also, they may experience some serious health problems that will result in higher than average veterinary bills. This covers the puppy price, crates, vaccines, food, toys, grooming, microchip, spaying or neutering, and complete medical exams.
This puppy from a mill may experience serious health problems in the future that will cost you thousands of dollars, a lot more than you would spend if youd just gotten one from a reputable breeder. Both breeds are not recommended for novice owners who dont have the time to train and exercise their dogs. Keeping them requires commitment, knowledge of their inherent characteristics and common health issues, time, effort, and money.
Breed Size: Who Stands Larger and Taller?
When the Germans in Rottweil decided to crossbreed their sheepdogs with the Romans’ mastiff-type dogs, they had in mind a large and strong hybrid dog who would pull carts of meat for butchers and defend their masters as well as their cattle and money.A look at the Rottweiler confirms that they were successful in their intent. In fact, a full-grown Rottweiler has a stout build which, coupled with its mean-looking face, will intimidate the strongest of men.As for the German Shepherd, Captain Max von Stephanitz, who is credited with the creation of the German Shepherd Dog as we know it today, was attracted by the breed’s intelligence and working strength: two traits that make a sturdy herding dog.Considering their physical traits, we clearly have two strong dogs, but there are clear differences in their weight and height, which also vary with sex.There will always be variations from different sources in general weight and height guidelines of all breeds and the above is a rough guide. As an example, my female German Shepherd is really big for a girl, nevertheless, she is proportionally built, which is what counts – she stands at 27ʺ tall and weighs 88lbs (40kg)!From the differences in weight and height, the Rottweiler stands out. The largest male Rottweiler would be 45lb (20.4kg) heavier and 1ʺ (2.5cm) taller than the largest male German Shepherd.The Rottweiler also has a stronger dog bite force when compared to the German Shepherd. Be aware though that there have been myths and misinterpretations surrounding the strength of dog bites.An experiment on animal bite force by Dr. Brady Barr found that the Rottweiler has a bite force equivalent to 328 PSI (pound-force per square inch) while that of the German Shepherd is equal to 238 PSI.If we were to stop here and gauge the strength of the two breeds by these physical aspects, we would hand over the trophy to the Rottweiler.By the way, if you are thinking about buying a product or toy for your dog, check out my favorite gear below. Also, check out the 10-year warranty on the dog bed!But does the strength of a dog breed rely solely on its physical build and power?
German Shepherds have had plenty of military experience, even though they’re traditionally herding dogs. In the 18th century, a military man named Captain Max von Stephanitz sought toAlthough he made a great herding dog, his characteristics made him the perfect candidate for the police academy. Off he went, studied hard, and excelled with flying colors. Ever since then, he has been one of theLike the Rottweiler, the Shepherd’s
Rottweilers areIt isn’t just their sheer size difference that makes them easy to tell apart. The Rottie is aAll Rotties have a short to medium-length double coat, and it is thick, dense, and shiny, and soft in texture. German Shepherds have the option ofRotties tend to sport the traditional black and tan coat with the traditional Rottie markings. Compared to the Shepherd, who sports a wider range of colors, including black and tan, blue, black, and white.
These breeds have distinct differences. Both breeds are typicallyRottweilers, on the other hand, were bred as guardians and protectors. They may not require as much exercise, but they can beThey’re both self-assured dogs that will quickly designate themselves as the leader without firm guidance. You can’t let them walk all over you, because if you do, they could become destructive and dangerous. They need aBoth types of dogs can be aloof and easygoing. They can also snuggle in your lap if you let them. But for the most part, both breeds are confident and courageous. They tend to beMany Rottweilers are known for being goofy and lovable at home with the family. German Shepherds are playful but a bit less silly. Both dogs can be
As Guardian Breeds
Both breeds haveBecause of these territorial and protective instincts, neither dog is particularly friendly with strangers. They have to
Whether you have a Rottie or a Shepherd, you have to know what it means to own a working dog. Both of these dogsIf you think that’s a lot, consider the American Kennel Club recommends German Shepherds get at leastWhen you’re not actively exercising with your dog, make sure it has
Rottweiler owners should commit to training their dogs correctly. Because these animals are so large and muscular,If you own either of these breeds,Rottweilers may beOn the other hand, German Shepherds are more likely to be motivated byA Rottweiler is probably more likely to look for a loophole in your rules, though. Therefore, you have to be strict with your training. Never let misbehavior slide, or your Rottie will learn how to manipulate you.When it comes to following commands, the German Shepherd tends to be quicker to learn. Once you teach them to do something, they’ll be steadfast. Still,
Both breeds areThe main concerns that affect the Rottie are hip and elbow dysplasia. This occurs when the bone and the socketThe Rottie is also at risk ofThe German Shepherd is also prone to hip and elbow dysplasia. Shepherds are amongst the most affected breeds of hip dysplasia. You can help to keep your German Shepherd’s hips and joints in top shape by using glucosamine supplements and making sure they have a soft but firm dog bed to rest on.German Shepherd breeders should only breed dogs with
TheAll dogs are different, and it may vary depending on your dog’sFor potentially dominant dog breeds such as these guys, it’s important to make them work for their food rather than giving it to them for free. Instead of just putting the food dish down, try training your dog and offering the food as a treat. You may think this is exhausting, but both breeds are bound to love the regimen. Even if you just ask for a paw, a
Both dog breeds have different grooming regimes, particularly if your German Shepherd is long-haired. They all haveShort-haired German Shepherds and Rottweilers have similar grooming needs in that they need brushing a few times a week. During the shedding seasons, this should be upped toThey both need bathing just as much as one another, approximatelyAlways be sure to use
The price of a Rottie pup from a reputable breeder usuallyYou also need to think about the ongoing costs of owning both breeds. Although there isn’t a huge difference, the cost of a Rottie over his lifetime will likely be more than a Shepherd due to their size.Rotties are large to giant-sized dogs, and bigger products usually come with a
Technically, there’s only really one ‘type’ of Rottweiler – the Rottweiler!But some breeders insist on breaking down the breed into subsections.Specialized and intentional breeding has created slight variations within the breed, but don’t be fooled into buying into the idea of the ‘American Rottweiler’ or the ‘German Rottweiler’.An American Rottweiler is really only a Rottweiler born in America.There is no real difference between an American or German Rottie.That said, the ‘Roman Rottweiler’ is bigger than its peers. But it’s less a natural type of Rottweiler, it’s more that the size has been bred in.These dogs will appear almost Mastiff-like. But by design.
German Shepherd types
Similar to Rottweilers, German Shepherds are German Shepherds.If they’re pedigree dogs, that means they’re ‘pure’, but there are no ‘types’ of GSD.That said, German Shepherds can be grouped by what’s known as ‘lines’.There are ‘show lines’ and ‘working lines’ and each is closely monitored and guarded by GSD aficionados.There are German show lines and American show lines, each differing slightly.The main difference is that the German show line requires hip certification to prove that work is being done to discourage the famously bad hip problems that Shepherds suffer from.Working line-wise, there are German lines and Czech lines.Each requires the dog to be hard working, agile and mentally stable.But the German lines have more emphasis on the dogs’ ability to settle down in a home environment.When we’re comparing the Rottweiler vs German Shepherd dogs we’ll be looking mostly at the breeds in general, though we will refer to type if it becomes relevant.So how does Rottweiler vs German Shepherd history compare?
Rottweilers are believed to come from the large ‘drover dogs’ of Ancient Rome.As the Romans conquered Europe, they took these trusty dogs with them everywhere they went. Why?Well, because they were guard dogs par excellence.They would be primarily utilised as guarders of cattle and other livestock, watching over their herds and flocks intently.They’d stop predators, poachers and indigenous attackers.Sometimes, the Roman Army’s dog handlers would employ their packs of drover dogs in hunts too.The name ‘Rottweiler’ didn’t come about until a large settlement bred the dogs in the German town of Rottweil.The early standard for pedigree Rottweilers was established in Germany way back in 1901.With the first Rotties coming over to America and Britain just before the Second World War.Ironically, their popularity in the UK grew as they were used as police and military dogs throughout the war against Germany.German Shepherds also have a strong working history.But there are also some big differences.
German Shepherd history
Compared to Rottweilers, German Shepherds are a rather young breed of dog.Originated as a cross breed between various different breeds of Shepherd, the ‘German’ variety that we know and love today wasn’t really seen until the very late 19th Century.They were bred as ‘the ultimate Shepherd’ and have a man called Max von Stephanitz to thank for their popularity.A former cavalry captain and ex-student of the Berlin Veterinary College, von Stephanitz was an ex-member of The Phylax Society, a dog development institution.The retired soldier nurtured and lauded the breed, espousing its values and pretty quickly convincing the world that the Schäferhunde is the very best in large Shepherd dog.As with Rottweilers, German Shepherds made their way out to the rest of Western Europe and into America in the 1930’s, quickly establishing themselves as immensely popular working dogs and pets.But what about the present day?How do these two breeds stack up against each other in terms of their apperance?
German Shepherd dog vs Rottweiler physical overview
The fundamental difference between these two comes in their appearance.Rottweilers are squat, weighty-looking and stocky.They have compact heads, straight backs and look like they could run through a wall.GSDs, meanwhile, are much more athletic looking.They’re still strong, but they are longer than they are tall, with slimmer builds and longer muzzles.German Shepherds’ tails are long and bushy, whereas their counterparts’ are short haired, though still long.There are a few other notable differences in the bodies of these two similar dogs.Their necks are particularly unalike; Rottweilers have strong, muscled and comparatively short necks.Whereas German Shepherds are known for their longer, slimmer necks.
Rottweiler dog vs German Shepherd size
Rottweilers compared to German Shepherds, well, both of these breeds are big.It’s important for prospective owners to realize just how big.Neither are the world’s largest breed of dog, that honor belongs to the Great Dane.But don’t underestimate just how big and heavy Rotties and German Shepherds can get.Rottweilers can weigh anywhere up to 115 lbs! And measure up to around 28” (up to their shoulders).These dogs are big, broad and packed with muscle.German Shepherds are just as tall as Rottweilers, coming in anywhere between 22” and 29”.Weight-wise, they’re a little lighter, averaging in at around 80 lbs.
Rottweiler vs German Shepherd grooming
Both breeds of dogs are easy to groom and care for. A brushing two or three times a week should suffice.Both need the odd nail trim, but be careful not to trim them too short.Rottweiler vs German Shepherd sheddingGerman Shepherds, by contrast, shed a fair amount. So make sure you’ve a good vacuum cleaner!But how does the Rottweiler vs German Shepherd personality stack up?
Rottweiler vs German Shepherd reputations
No dogs are inherantly ‘bad’. But some have bad reputations, based upon their traits.Years of humans utilizing large dogs like Rottweilers and German Shepherds as guard dogs and using them in the military and in police forces has earned them both an unfair reputation.Anyone with a working knowledge or even brief amount of experience with either breed of dog will know that that they are neither violent nor aggressive when trained.The large teeth and loud bark of the GSD and the stout build and mean-looking ‘angry’ face of a fully-grown Rottweiler may look intimidating.But their reputations are not always fairly assigned.Both breeds can be big softies if trained and socialized correctly, and bred from friendly parents.It is equally important with both to meet the pup’s parents and assess their temperaments, as well as to really thoroughly socialize the puppy from the day they come home.So what do we know for sure about Rottweiler vs German Shepherd temperament?
German Shepherd dog vs Rottweiler temperament
GSDs are highly intelligent, devoted, dependable and loyal.And so too are most Rottweilers.Neither breed is likely to be pushy with strangers, or overly bouncy.However, both breeds are often wary of strangers if not thoroughly socialized, and have been known to become aggressive even with their own families.One study has shown that 15% of dogs with severe aggression are German Shepherds and around 5% by Rottweilers.But given how much more common GSDs are than Rotties, you can see that the risk with either is high.German Shepherds have been shown in several studies to be a high risk breed for bites, even when the odds were adjusted to take into account their popularity.The GSD has also been recorded as being the breed responsible for the second highest amount of fatalities.Rottweilers and GSDs are calm and self-assured, but Rotties tend to be a little more aloof and able to enjoy their own company more.German Shepherds are slightly more vocal.The only possible downside to the temperaments of these animals comes from their natural instincts.Both have the urge to guard and protect.
Rottweiler vs German Shepherd as guard dogs
These are the top two guard dogs on the planet.They’re both herding dogs by nature, but guarding is also a huge strength of both breeds.Perhaps Rottweilers appear a little more fierce, so may be preferred for this purpose.But you will need to seriously consider whether this is a trait you want in a family pet.Because while they can be amazing companions, both dogs have a strong protective streak.
German Shepherd vs Rottweiler socialization
In order to help a Rottweiler or German Shepherd fit into your home, the key is socialization. And lots of it.Hours of dedication, patience and hard work may be required.You need to make sure that you dog is trained and calm around other people and dogs.These dogs are not small.You are duty bound (not to mention legally required) to ensure that your dog is safe.And you do this with socialization.Make sure that from 8 weeks to 14 weeks old visitors come to the house every single day.A range of ages and types is ideal. From noisy babies, to the elderly, people in bright clothing to men with beards.Make sure they are comfortable with anyone coming and going.You will also need to take them somewhere busy every day, to begin with due to lack of vaccinations they will need to be carried.Meet as many people as possible.Once they are three months old you can reduce the intensity, but it will still need to be at least a couple of times a week.Both breeds are hugely alike when it comes to socializing and its importance.You’re on an even keel when it comes to Rottweiler vs German Shepherd socialization.But what about training?
German Shepherd dog vs Rottweiler training
There is little contrast in the way a dog owner should approach training a Rottweiler or GSD.As with all dogs, treats should be used as encouragement and punishment-based training is not advised.All dogs need training and boundaries, but this is especially true with larger dogs.After all, who wants a crazy 115 lb dog running amok around their house?!Extensive training is also needed to ensure that Rottweilers and German Shepherds are obedient, especially went out walking in public.Fortunately, they are both pretty clever and quick to learn.
Rottweiler vs German Shepherd intelligence
Another area where the two breeds can’t really be separated is intelligence. Both Rotties and GSDs are about as sharp as dogs get.They both have high canine IQs and can learn and retain new information with just a few repetitions.Where some real differences emerge is when we start to look at Rottweiler vs German Shepherd Dog health.Although there is one big similarity.
Health Issues Affecting Both GSDs and Rotties
No lover of dogs wants to think too much about their lovable canine pals in pain.But it’s to do a disservice to your pet to ignore the very distinct possibility that, one day, they might get sick.It pays to be armed with a little knowledge about what afflictions your dog is particularly susceptible to.That way you can look out for possible symptoms in the future.Each breed here has its medical quirks, with them being more genetically predisposed than the other to certain conditions.But there is one major health issue that Rottweilers and German Shepherds share…Specifically, hip and elbow dysplasia.It’s a genetic trait that, while inherited, is often exacerbated by environmental factors.Dysplasia refers to the abnormal function of any major joint and leads to discomfort, lameness, arthritis and extreme pain in some cases.One cause can be size. Large dogs are more likely to get hip and elbow dysplasia than smaller dogs. Inbreeding in the breed’s early stages is perhaps the most notable reason, however.Don’t let it put you off the breeds though, just make sure that you only buy a puppy whose parents both have good hip and elbow scores.Now let’s take a look at those health differences you’ll need to consider.
Rotties have a slightly higher chance of developing osteosarcoma, or bone cancer.They also have a higher chance of suffering with von Willebrand’s Disease (vWD), a bleeding disorder not dissimilar to haemophilia.Progressive Retinal Atrophy (PRA) is also noted as an affliction more prevalent among Rottweilers than many other breeds.Potential owners should also be aware that Rottweilers sometimes show a tendency to suffer with thyroid problems and Panosteitis, an inflammation of the bones in the limbs.If you buy a Rottie puppy you’ll need to make sure the parents also have clear PRA DNA tests, clear vWD tests and no family history of the other issues.
German Shepherd health
‘Canine degenerative myelopathy’, otherwise known as ‘chronic degenerative radiculomyelopathy’ is not uncommon among German Shepherd dogs.It’s an incurable disease of the spinal cord caused by a gene mutation.German Shepherds are predisposed to suffer with musculoskeletal diseases and problems more than almost any other breed of dog.Osteoarthritis is also not uncommon in the breed.Like the Rottie, GSDs are also known to get vWD.
German Shepherd vs Rottweiler life expectancy
The average German Shepherd, compared to a Rottweiler, will live longer.Rottweilers are only expected to live between eight and ten years.German Shepherds however, live anywhere between nine and twelve years. The average GSD living to 10.95 years
German Shepherds vs Rottweiler puppies
It doesn’t matter which breed of dog you end up choosing, you should go about selecting a breeder and puppy the same way.Do your research. Take your time.Select a respectable and recommended breeder.You’ll want someone who knows their stuff, only expects their dogs to produce one litter a year maximum and generally seems above board.It is vital that the breeder allows you to meet the puppy’s mother and you can do so in the house in which she and the puppies live.With guarding breeds it’s also a good idea to meet the father, to make sure of his temperament.Make sure the puppies are bright, alert, happy and playful.
Rottweiler vs German Shepherd price
In the battle of the budgets, it’s tough to split the cost between these two breeds.If you’re able to adopt instead of shop, the fees you pay will dictated by the rescue center and probably just cover costs.Although, of course, you’re very welcome to donate more.If you’re going to buy a Rottweiler or German Shepherd, as with all dogs purchases, the amount you pay – again – will depend on where you buy it from. And if the dog is a pedigree or not.As a guide, though? You’re looking at around $1,500 – $2,500 per puppy.Less often for older dogs.You can double those figures for a breedable and/or show quality young pup.
German Shepherd or Rottweiler for family
Both German Shepherds and Rottweilers can be viewed as controversial choices, due to their guarding natures.But despite their big sizes and fearsome reputations, both German Shepherds and Rottweilers can make great family pets.If trained and socialized, of course.But if you have young children you will need to carefully consider whether you are willing to take on one of these breeds, given the frequency of attacks on children under the age of 12.Both breeds can be quite protective of their families, in fact.And are often said to act really quite silly and clown-like when relaxing at home with their human pals.