If you love big dogs, you might consider getting a German Shepherd or a Doberman Pinscher. Youve probably seen both working with the police or military. But all large-breed canines are not the same.
Breed Comparison Height 22-26 Inches Weight 50-90 Pounds Temperament Confident, Courageous, Smart Energy High Health Average Lifespan 12-14 Years Puppy Prices $1,000 and Up Height 24-28 Inches Weight 60-100 Pounds Temperament Loyal, Fearless, Alert Energy High Health Average Lifespan 10-12 Years Puppy Prices $1,000 and Up
Some American soldiers brought these dogs home, and movies like Rin-Tin-Tin and Strongheart made the breed somewhat famous. In 1942, the Doberman Pinscher Club of America was asked to provide canines for the Marine Corps War Dog Training Facility in North Carolina. As the war came to a close, German Shepherds superseded Dobermans as the most popular military dog.
Both breeds are large-sized dogs that range from 50 to 100 pounds and stand about 26 to 27 inches tall at one year of age. While both of these dogs have an athletic build, Dobermans are taller and thinner, whereas shepherds are stockier and shorter. Theyre almost so intelligent that they get bored with menial tasks and try to outwit you, which can make them hard to train.
Kids should understand how to best interact with these large pets so they are seen as leaders of the pack instead of puppies or enemies. Its safe to say that long, tedious walks around the block arent going to hit the spot for either of these guys. They both make great jogging partners and love to partake in agility courses, fetching games, and practically anything you can think of!
Dobermans rival Labs in their activity levels, and German Shepherds likely will exceed both in the terms of exercise commitment as a dog owner. Some people say Dobermans arent good around children or small pets, but that depends on the dogs training and personality. To teach both the German Shepherd and the Doberman polite pooch manners, they must be socialized well as a pup.
They should also be tested for von Willebrands disease , which is directly inherited and can cause serious blood loss from minor wounds. The German Shepherd needs high-quality dog food that can support their activity levels and rapid bone growth. Kibbles designed for large breed puppies will help to control this rapid bone growth.
The difference between basic store-branded kibble and high-quality trusted brands can be your pup living his healthiest life possible. Large dogs with deep chests are the most at risk , and both the Dobie and the Shepherd tick these boxes. Never feed your pooch immediately before or after exercise, and spread your dogs daily food across at least two sittings.
Which can leave you with tumbleweeds of fur all over your home as they transition from winter to summer and vice versa. Otherwise, youll probably end up paying much more in behavioral training and liability costs should something happen. Although neither of these guys is the most expensive dogs to care for, they are usually higher than the average canine considering their size and needs.
Understanding this and catering to their physical and psychological needs can produce an ideal relationship between humans and these canines.
Can a Doberman beat a German Shepherd?
In a real fight the Doberman might be the winner, because Doberman is a very aggressive and powerful breed of dog that has the ability to fight against a German Shepherd. And a Doberman has stronger bite force of 245 PSI compared to German Shepherd with a bite force of 238 PSI.
Why do police use German Shepherds instead of Dobermans?
Why do the Police Use German Shepherds as Police Dogs? The German Shepherd is renowned for its strength, trainability, obedience, and high intelligence. This makes the breed ideal for several lines of work. … Lastly, German Shepherd dogs are lighter than other breeds that have a history of working as police dogs.
What dog is better than GSD?
King Shepherds are bigger than German Shepherds and more powerful and muscular. They are comparatively less aggressive and very intelligent and quick learners. They are intelligent, powerful, loyal and less aggressive than German Shepherds.
Are Dobermans the strongest dog?
Doberman Pinscher.. With what may be considered the strongest bite ( a reported 600 pounds of pressure ), Dobermans come in at number four for aggression. Their strength and intelligence can make them aggressive towards strangers and occasionally their owners.
In this article were going to evaluate the similarities and differences between one of the most popular family dogs the German Shepherd, and a close alternative the Doberman Pinscher.
Both GSDs and Dobermans are large and powerfully built but not to the point of becoming slow or clumsy due to excess weight. Dobermans have more of a square build compared to the German Shepherds rectangular and sloping silhouette.
Both dogs weigh in the range of 75 to 95 pounds, giving the German Shepherd a stockier appearance than the Doberman. Dobermans can be blue, fawn, or tan in addition to black, but theyll all have rust or brown markings in certain areas such as above the eyes and on the lower legs. If you dont crop your Dobermans ears, they will fold down near the base, tending to be wide and floppy but not excessively long.
Docking means the breeder or veterinarian cuts the dogs tail to the breed-specific standard length when the pup is a few days old. If you happen to have a Doberman with a full tail, it will be medium in length and rope-like, curving gradually upward from the midsection to the tip. On the contrary, German Shepherds have a long plush tail that they carry low unless working or showing emotion.
Although a German Shepherds coat can vary quite a bit, most have medium to long hair with a dense undercoat. German Shepherds require more grooming than Dobermans, but both breeds need regular brushing to keep the undercoat in check. German Shepherds require special attention to their fur when they blow their coats during seasonal shedding this typically occurs twice a year.
If you do end up playing outside with your GSD or Doberman on a hot summers day, try to take frequent water breaks in the shade to help them cool down. If you really want to play it safe, temperatures above 85 to 90 degrees Fahrenheit may even warrant restrictions on any outdoor excursions for either breed. Karl Friedrich Louis Dobermann perfected the Doberman so that it would be able to work tirelessly with him throughout the day and without complaint.
GSDs and Pinschers are similar in that their strong work ethic and high intelligence necessitate both lots of exercise and plenty of social interaction. Left to their own devices for long periods of time, or without sufficient exercise, can lead to more destructive behavior around the house and yard. Being such intelligent animals, both German Shepherds and Doberman Pinschers need plenty of mental stimulation to keep their active minds occupied.
We know what personality traits Dobermans and German Shepherds have in common they share loyalty , fearlessness, independence, protectiveness , and intelligence. At this point, you may be thinking that other than a bushy tail, extra brushing, and some differences in appearance, German Shepherds and Doberman Pinscher are pretty much the same. However, when analyzing differences in temperament and personality, well start to notice more obvious distinctions between the breeds.
The German Shepherds herding background developed their intelligence, cooperative mindset, and protective instincts that extend to groups as well as individuals. However, their high intensity and drive common amongst herding breeds can make them susceptible to anxiety and nervousness. Using Dobermans as bodyguards, for property patrol, and in the military, handlers encouraged the dogs to be aggressive and intimidating.
Dobermans remain exceptional guard dogs, although breeders have successfully managed to produce a much friendlier version that is more suitable as a family pet. Dog aggression is an acceptable trait in the show ring for Dobermans and one that breeding has propagated for generations. In Dobermans, according to professional dog trainer John Soares , the hunter and mastiff-type ancestry causes them to vigorously defend their space biting only as a last resort.
However, reflective of the terrier and Molossoid influences, when a Doberman does bite, its with the full intent of causing harm. German Shepherds, on the other hand, move more readily into an intruders space and give less warning before biting. German Shepherds are involved in more biting incidents than Dobermans, and are only slightly behind Pit Bulls at No.
Some experts actually discourage formal protective training for German Shepherds or Dobermans, citing obedience as the more important goal. According to Doberman Planet , GSDs fall a little short of the average for pet dogs, which is 269 pounds of pressure per square inch. This statement is true for pretty much any dog they can become dangerous without proper training, socialization, and human interaction.
Insurers will simply disregard your dogs training or individual personality once a breed is ruled dangerous. As large deep-chested breeds, both Dobermans and German Shepherds are susceptible to a condition called bloat. The stomach swells to several times its regular size from gas and fluid build-up after a meal and other exacerbating conditions.
Hemophilia a clotting disorder that affects a different pathway than von Willebrands but has similar results. Parvo a life-threatening virus that more commonly affects puppies with compromised immunities, causing bloody diarrhea and vomiting Dilatative cardiomyopathy Dobermans are overrepresented. An enlarged heart chamber with thinning walls greatly shortens the lives of affected dogs.
Their extreme focus has enabled them to become the gold standard in the military, and iconic figures in the police force.
When it comes down to our family safety, we want to go for only the best and most reliant options. Choosing the perfect guard dog among the numerous dog breeds can be a challenging task. However, many people prefer the classic choice of German Shepherd or its close alternative to the Doberman breed.
Pro Tip: It is usually a bad idea to get an adult dog without training, as this will endanger you, your friends, and your family. As long as you invest enough time into training, both dog breeds will show intelligent behavior when it comes to guarding and protecting their owners.
For their training, German Shepherds prefer large yards and fields with plenty of space to run around. Interesting Fact: Both dogs are known to serve and work for military forces, police, and other guarding jobs. They both learn fast due to their high intelligence level, but their training has to be consistent with daily exercises.
The dog is a proud owner of a square built body with refined muscles and a powerful jaw. With simple daily brushing, the short hair is easy to maintain and avoid extreme shedding and intense grooming. Pro Tip: Before purchasing a puppy of the two god breeds, make sure to run some medical tests.
There is nothing worse than bringing a puppy home for safety measures and discovering that it has crucial health problems. While German Shepherds are slightly higher more popular, many happy owners of the Doberman breed will argue with that statement.
Doberman Pinschers were also developed in Germany, by Karl Friedrich Louis Dobermann. Like the German Shepherd, the Doberman is also aDobermann owned a local dog pound, and heThe Doberman has also been used in the military and police service over the years. U.S. soldiers noticed that their
Herding dogs tend to be more intelligent than working dogs. However, Dobermans are one of the two working-class canine breeds that have made it onto the top 10 most intelligent dogs. Dobermans are #3 on the list. They’reDobermans are incredibly loyal, which makes themGerman Shepherds may beBoth of these dogs score high on a trait called the
In The Home
This loyalty makes themGerman Shepherds are part of the herding group, whereas Dobermans are in the working group of canines. But these groups were classified together until 1983. Herders tend to beThe working group of dogs has fewer specifications. For example, a Husky is a working dog because it can pull a sled. And the Doberman was
Both of these breeds need plenty of exercise and get bored easily. If you don’t walk them before and after work, theyAs working dogs with lots of energy, theirThey both make great jogging partners and love to partake in agility courses, fetching games, and practically anything you can think of! Dobermans rival Labs in their activity levels, and German Shepherds likely will exceed both in the terms of exercise commitment as a dog owner.They’ll also need plenty of
Although both breeds have been bred as guard dogs, they’reNo dog should be considered a biter because of its breed. Aggressiveness is often aSome people say Dobermans aren’t good around children or small pets, but that depends on the dog’s training and personality. German Shepherds tend to be less stubborn and more easygoing around children.Because these dogs have guarding tendencies, they
Because of inbreeding, both breeds have anThe main health concerns for German shepherds are:They should get regular checkups and have special attention directed to the joints. The main health concerns for Dobermans are:Dobermans should have their hips and heart examined regularly. They should also be tested for von Willebrand’s disease, which is directly inherited and can cause serious blood loss from minor wounds.
The cost of a German Shepherd puppy and a Dobie pup from a reputable breeder will start from aroundIt’s important toYou also need to remember the costs that pile up on top of initial puppy prices. Getting your pup vaccinated and attending puppy health checkups all cost money. Not forgetting
How do their appearances differ?
The Doberman, at 26 to 28 inches tall, somewhat towers over the 22 to 26-inch tall GSD. Dobermans have more of a square build compared to the German Shepherd’s rectangular and sloping silhouette.Both dogs weigh in the range of 75 to 95 pounds, giving the German Shepherd a stockier appearance than the Doberman.The Doberman’s muscles, however, appear more defined than the Shepherd’s. In each breed, the male should be larger and more muscular than the female.Color variations differ as well. German Shepherds can be solid red, tan, black, or red and black. Less common coat colors you can also see are white, blue, silver, and liver.Here is a complete list of standard and rare German Shepherd colors.Dobermans can be blue, fawn, or tan in addition to black, but they’ll all have rust or brown markings in certain areas such as above the eyes and on the lower legs.Although quite rare, white Doberman do exist as well.
What Are The Exercise Requirements?
Both Dobermans and German Shepherds were bred to be versatile working dogs with excellent endurance.Karl Friedrich Louis Dobermann perfected the Doberman so that it would be able to work tirelessly with him throughout the day and without complaint.German Shepherds spent their days herding sheep and protecting them from dangerous predators.GSDs and Pinschers are similar in that their strong work ethic and high intelligence necessitate both lots of exercise and plenty of social interaction.Left to their own devices for long periods of time, or without sufficient exercise, can lead to more destructive behavior around the house and yard.German Shepherds and Dobermans alike need as much as two hours of exercise per day.
These Dogs Have Much Different Temperaments
We know what personality traits Dobermans and German Shepherds have in common – they share loyalty, fearlessness, independence, protectiveness, and intelligence.At this point, you may be thinking that other than a bushy tail, extra brushing, and some differences in appearance, German Shepherds and Doberman Pinscher are pretty much the same.However, when analyzing differences in temperament and personality, we’ll start to notice more obvious distinctions between the breeds.
German Shepherds originated from a long line of herding dogs, whereas the Doberman’s sole original purpose was as a protector of people and property.The German Shepherd’s herding background developed their intelligence, cooperative mindset, and protective instincts that extend to groups as well as individuals.In general, German Shepherds tend to be very smart and playful, yet task-oriented. Their willingness to please also makes them easy to train.However, their high intensity and drive – common amongst herding breeds – can make them susceptible to anxiety and nervousness.
The Doberman Pinscher, who likely inherited traits from the Rottweiler, Manchester Terrier, German Pinscher, and Weimaraner, once had a well-established reputation for viciousness.Using Dobermans as bodyguards, for property patrol, and in the military, handlers encouraged the dogs to be aggressive and intimidating.Dobermans remain exceptional guard dogs, although breeders have successfully managed to produce a much friendlier version that is more suitable as a family pet.With this in mind, German Shepherds are likely easier to train, and better around children and other household pets.German Shepherds tend to bond closely with one family member, much like a Doberman.Dog aggression is an acceptable trait in the show ring for Dobermans and one that breeding has propagated for generations.A well-bred Doberman, however, is more likely than a GSD to greet strangers in a friendly manner.German Shepherds are often aloof, albeit civil, towards unfamiliar people.For the most part, you should still use caution when introducing these dogs to your guests and other dogs.
You may have insurance concerns
Insurance companies commonly place German Shepherds and Dobermans on uninsurable lists. Renting a property can be a hassle if you own an Alsatian or a Doberman.Insurers will simply disregard your dog’s training or individual personality once a breed is ruled dangerous.
Dobermans as a Family Dog
However, Dobermans are stubborn, while Shepherds can be anti-social, so if they are not used to children or other pets in the house, they can act aggressively and refuse to follow commands.Even if you do not have children or other pets in your home, the situation might change during the 10-year lifespan. Do not make the mistake of ignoring these factors of training and early socialization.
German Shepherds as a Family Dog
German Shepherds are less stubborn, learn faster, and are more easygoing, while Dobermans are more playful and charismatic. However, try not to leave them alone with really young children and encourage your children and other family members to participate in training sessions.
Living Environment Considerations
When it comes to training, as similar as these breeds are, you will notice personality and temperament differences.Shepherds are more temperamental and have higher energy levels, and they do not like closed living areas. With that, Dobermans tend to show aggression more often than Shepherds. It can be considered an advantage, as well as a disadvantage. It all depends on the situation and if there is a real threat.As long as you invest enough time into training, both dog breeds will show intelligent behavior when it comes to guarding and protecting their owners.
Doberman vs. German Shepherd – Size Differences
The Doberman breed is the larger one, especially if it is a male dog. Its weight is around 70 to 100 pounds, and its height in adulthood reaches up to 28 inches. The Doberman females weigh 60 to 90 pounds and stand 24 to 26 inches tall.The dog is a proud owner of a square built body with refined muscles and a powerful jaw. Dobermans have a short coat that comes in various colors. With simple daily brushing, the short hair is easy to maintain and avoid extreme shedding and intense grooming.German Shepherds weigh 50 to 90 pounds and are 22 to 26 inches tall. Like Dobermans, Shepherd males are at the higher and bigger ranges than females. Yet, it is not a big difference, and both breeds are fast and muscular.This dog breed has a wolf-like appearance with its pointed ears and a thick double-layer medium-length coat. Shepherds require more grooming, as they shed a lot. However, with the right environmental conditions, exercise regime, and nutrition, you can minimize the shedding frequency.
Both dog breeds are similar in many ways and raised to serve humans, yet each has its unique traits. While German Shepherds are slightly higher more popular, many happy owners of the Doberman breed will argue with that statement. The perfect choice is a subjective matter that depends on your experience with the dog and your preferences in traits that your dog must possess.I hope this article has given you a head start on your research about which one is right for you. The great news is that there really isn’t a bad choice! It’s more about which matches your lifestyle best.Thanks for reading!