Clumping vs Non Clumping Litter?

Choosing the best cat litter for your cat can be a difficult choice simply because there are so many options available. Clumping cat litters have become widely available and very popular, but nonclumping cat litters are still commonly used, too. So, is clumping or nonclumping litter better? Well, lets look at some of the pros and cons of each litter type.

Nonclumping litter is typically made of clay, though there are other types available such as plant-based alternatives (e.g., pine, corn, wheat, beet pulp, and wood). There also alternative all-natural fibers that can help clump the cat litter tightly.

Is clumping or non-clumping litter better?

Non-clumping absorbs more of the waste, while the clumping litter traps more of the odor. … Clumping litter is heavy and can be expensive, but it is also convenient and you can go longer without box …more. Non-clumping litter is cheaper and cats seem to prefer it’s texture.

Why is non-clumping cat litter better?

Non-clumping cat litter is good at removing odors associated with cat urine because it has the ability to absorb relatively large volumes of urine. … Some people prefer non-clumping litter because it is often less expensive than clumping litter, and others choose it because their cats prefer it.

Is clumping litter bad for cats?

Kittens are curious creatures, tending to investigate things with both their paws and mouths. In the process, they may ingest their own litter. Clumping clay litters can be particularly dangerous to the digestive tract, creating a rock-like obstruction as the litter hardens.

Is non-clumping litter unsanitary?

Non-clumping litters don’t clump around your cats “solids”, so they can get spread around and contaminate the rest of the litter, which isn’ t only unsanitary but can also be dangerous as cat poo may carry Toxoplasmosis or other harmful bacteria.

When you remove clumps, the litter box can be topped up after a few days. This is much easier to do than replacing the entire litter in the box or pan.

Urine is absorbed and forms clumps which can be scooped out and removed easily Clumping also helps dry out cat poop that makes it easier to remove As clumps absorb urine and dry out cat poop, it helps control odors in the home Because its so good at soaking up any type of moisture, some garage owners use clumping litter for water and oil spills.

It can also save you money because you only need to remove the clumps and the remainder of the litter can still be used, providing little waste. Because clumping litter forms hardened clumps, makes it easy to scoop and as a result, makes cleaning out the litter box a great deal faster. It wont dry out cat poop or compact urine into clumps.

For this reason, it doesnt control odors as well as clumping litter. The main difference is that it doesnt form clumps, which means that the only time you change this litter is when you it becomes saturated with urine. At this point the litter box will need to be emptied, cleaned, dried and then re-filled with new litter.Advertisements

By changing it once a week, it will help to control odors in the home. Silica crystal litters have been around for many years and do an excellent job of clumping and absorbing urine and cat poop. Natural or biodegradable litter have become more popular in recent years.

Makes it very fast to clean a litter Cheap when compared to all other forms of litter Good at drying out cat poop Good at drying out cat urine and absorbing smells The clumping can cause blockages if accidentally ingested Not suitable for kittens Not environmentally friendly in any way However, bentonite clay comes from strip mines, leading to environmental concerns.

There is also plenty of anecdotal evidence that if a cat accidentally ingests the clumping clay litter, then it can cause blockages in your cat.Advertisements For this reason, its highly recommended that no type of litter should ever be flushed because it could clog pipes. Used in most cat shelters as it doesnt risk the potential health problems of clumping litters Only needs to be fully replaced once a week Is a cheaper litter to buy

Not environmentally friendly in any way Smells if not regularly replaced Needs to be bagged and put in the garbage which then goes to land fill sites For the manual self-cleaning boxes, the clumping style litter is a better choice.

Cat litter should be comfortable and safe for your cat to use, easily cover up their poop and pee, and do a good job of masking unpleasant aromas. When choosing a litter, one of the basic choices you have is whether to opt for clumping or nonclumping cat litter.

Image Credit: Left Clumping (Sai Jirawadee, Shutterstock); Right NonClumping (New Africa, Shutterstock) Pros Easier to scoop Box does not need emptying as often Use less litter A bag will usually last longer Minimal dust production Less expensive to buy Better odor control

Litter box is more difficult to clean Requires frequent changing Can emit odors after a few days ImageProductDetails
Best Clumping Purina Tidy Max 99.9% dust-free Contains moisture activated Power Pieces Can help halt ammonia odors for up to 2 weeks CHECK PRICE Best NonClumping Cat’s Pride Premium Fresh & Clean Helps stop the growth of unpleasant odor Formulated with moisture-activated absorption Low-dust and tracking formula CHECK PRICE Purina guarantees that it will retain odor for 10 days when used as directed, enhanced by its deodorizing ingredients, and it has a low dust formula that makes it convenient and tidier for use.

Clumps can be removed, negating the need to empty and clean out the litter tray as frequently. It requires less frequent changing than the nonclumping variety, and it allows you to skim off the clumps that have been formed when your cat pees and poops in their litter. Good quality clumping litter is easier to clean, however, because urine is not allowed to pool at the bottom of the tray.

However, some clumping litter emits dust when pouring, and this can also be tracked through the house by your cats as they stand in it and transfer it onto the floor. It can hold up to 100% of its own weight in litter, and it does a good job of absorbing heavy liquids. These needed frequent cleaning and clearing out because they did not retain urine, which pooled at the bottom of the litter.

You simply empty the tray, clean it, and replace it with fresh litter. Because it does not usually produce clouds of dust, nonclumping litter does not usually track through the house as easily, and you shouldnt find the floor covered in dusty pawprints.

There are many kinds of cat litter out there finding the one thats best for you can seem daunting. The cat litter aisle is chocked full of bags, boxes and jugs. How do you start narrowing down your options?

There are many factors to take into consideration, like natural vs. clay or scented vs. unscented, but one of the best places to start is to decide whether you want a clumping or nonclumping litter. Nonclumping litters dont clump around your cats solids, so they can get spread around and contaminate the rest of the litter, which isnt only unsanitary but can also be dangerous as cat poo may carry Toxoplasmosis or other harmful bacteria.

Clumping litters trap liquids before they seep to the bottom of the box.

Non-Clumping Cat Litter

Some of the first commercially available cat litters were of the nonclumping type. Why? Nonclumping cat litter is good at removing odors associated with cat urine because it has the ability to absorb relatively large volumes of urine. While there are non-scented litters available, some nonclumping litters also have additional additives, such as baking soda or charcoal, which are designed to help control unpleasant odors.As the litter becomes saturated, however, urine may begin to pool in the bottom of the cat litter box. Therefore, removing soiled, nonclumping litter is often difficult without changing the entire box. Many who use nonclumping cat litter find that they need to be replaced the litter and clean the litter box at least once a week.Nonclumping litter is typically made of clay, though there are other types available such as plant-based alternatives (e.g., pine, corn, wheat, beet pulp, and wood). Some people prefer nonclumping litter because it is often less expensive than clumping litter, and others choose it because their cats prefer it.

Clumping Cat Litter

Clumping cat litters are those that are designed so that urine and feces can be removed easily from the box without having to empty the entire box. Most contain a material known as bentonite that allows the litter to form a nice solid clump as the litter absorbs liquid. There also alternative all-natural fibers that can help clump the cat litter tightly.Once the litter is clumped together, it can be removed from the litter box—along with any feces in the box—relatively easily. Just scoop out the soiled litter from the box and leave the clean litter in its place. The ability to scoop and remove soiled litter from the box means that the box stays cleaner longer. As soiled litter is removed from the box, it can simply be replenished by adding an equal amount of fresh litter.However, that does not mean that cat litter boxes filled with clumping cat litter never need to be emptied and cleaned. It only means that the task can be performed less frequently than with the nonclumping litters. Boxes containing clumping litter still need to be emptied, cleaned, and refilled with fresh litter at least once a month (based on a one cat home, or one cat litter box). If your cat produces an especially high volume of urine or if you have multiple cats, this will need to be done more frequently.

Types of Cat Litter

Nonclumping cat litter does not form any type of clumps. It is the original type of cat litter and has been around for many years.It’s main benefits are:Because no clumps are formed, cat poop will simply sit as it was left, on top of the litter or covered up by your cat.It won’t dry out cat poop or compact urine into clumps. For this reason, it doesn’t control odors as well as clumping litter.The main difference is that it doesn’t form clumps, which means that the only time you change this litter is when you it becomes saturated with urine.At this point the litter box will need to be emptied, cleaned, dried and then re-filled with new litter.AdvertisementsCat experts recommend that nonclumping cat litter should be changed once per week.By changing it once a week, it will help to control odors in the home.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Clumping Cat Litter

Now we know how clumping and nonclumping litter differs, here are the pros and cons:

Our Favorite Clumping Cat Litter:

The Purina Tidy Cats Instant Action Clumping Cat Litter is a clay cat litter. Purina guarantees that it will retain odor for 10 days when used as directed, enhanced by its deodorizing ingredients, and it has a low dust formula that makes it convenient and tidier for use.

Overview of Clumping Cat Litter:

Clumping cat litter is usually made using a material called bentonite, although some litters use other materials and may use all-natural clumping material. The clumping material forms into a solid clump as the litter takes on liquid, usually in the form of cat urine. This prevents urine from reaching the bottom of the tray, and the clumps can retain odor as well as liquid, which can help reduce the smell of cat urine and cat poop in the cat litter room.Clumps can be removed, negating the need to empty and clean out the litter tray as frequently. The litter boxes do still need to be emptied, but this can usually be done once a week to once a month, depending on urine production level and the quality of the litter used, rather than every couple of days.Clumping cat litter is relatively easy to use. It requires less frequent changing than the nonclumping variety, and it allows you to skim off the clumps that have been formed when your cat pees and poops in their litter. However, some of the clay-based clumping cat litter has a reputation for forming an almost cement-like bond at the bottom of a litter tray, and this can make it difficult to get the litter box completely spotless. Good quality clumping litter is easier to clean, however, because urine is not allowed to pool at the bottom of the tray.Clumping cat litter is considered cleaner. Urine does not pool at the bottom of the tray, and cat poop picks up the clumping cat litter more easily than it does nonclumping. However, some clumping litter emits dust when pouring, and this can also be tracked through the house by your cats as they stand in it and transfer it onto the floor.

Our Favorite Non-Clumping Litter:

Cat’s Pride Premium Clay Cat Litter is an absorbent but nonclumping cat litter. It can hold up to 100% of its own weight in litter, and it does a good job of absorbing heavy liquids. The litter has a light fragrance that helps to mask the smell of litter and it does not use harsh chemicals to achieve results.

Overview of Non-Clumping Cat Litter:

Nonclumping cat litter would have been the original choice. It would have included materials like sand and torn-up newspaper. These needed frequent cleaning and clearing out because they did not retain urine, which pooled at the bottom of the litter. Modern nonclumping litter is usually made from a clay material. Nonclumping materials that retain odors are usually chosen, but some litter includes additional materials that not only cover odors but mask them. Materials like charcoal, for example, work as a deodorizer.Nonclumping cat litter is very simple to use. You simply empty the tray, clean it, and replace it with fresh litter. While the process is simple, it does require more frequent cleaning of the tray. It is difficult to scoop poop and other litter from the box.Because it does not usually produce clouds of dust, nonclumping litter does not usually track through the house as easily, and you shouldn’t find the floor covered in dusty pawprints. However, the litter box itself can become very dirty. Urine pools more easily at the bottom of the tray, and you will have to do a full litter box change more frequently.